Bank Branches › New York › Erie County › 5491 Sheridan Dr
Full-service office · FDIC office no. 439650
Five Star Bank
5491 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14221
Open · June 2026
$146M
deposits, 2026
2005
established
71st
of 202 in county
2
names on the sign
| Date | Bank on the sign | Deposits | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 30 2026 | Five Star Bank | $146M | −2% |
| Jun 30 2025 | Five Star Bank | $150M | +1% |
| Jun 30 2024 | Five Star Bank | $149M | +25% |
| Jun 30 2023 | Five Star Bank | $119M | +12% |
| Jun 30 2022 | Five Star Bank | $106M | +18% |
| Jun 30 2021 | Five Star Bank | $90.0M | +14% |
| Jun 30 2020 | Five Star Bank | $79.1M | +22% |
| Jun 30 2019 | Five Star Bank | $64.9M | −10% |
| Jun 30 2018 | Five Star Bank | $71.8M | +8% |
| Jun 30 2017 | Five Star Bank | $66.7M | +30% |
| Jun 30 2016 | Five Star Bank | $51.4M | +1% |
| Jun 30 2015 | Five Star Bank | $50.9M | +6% |
| Jun 30 2014 | Five Star Bank | $48.0M | +3% |
| Jun 30 2013 | Five Star Bank | $46.4M | −5% |
| Jun 30 2012 | Five Star Bank | $49.0M | −7% |
| Jun 30 2011 | Five Star Bank | $52.8M | −12% |
| Jun 30 2010 | Five Star Bank | $59.7M | +130% |
| Jun 30 2009 | Five Star Bank | $25.9M | +88% |
| Jun 30 2008 | Five Star Bank | $13.8M | −19% |
| Jun 30 2007 | Five Star Bank | $17.1M | +57% |
| Jun 30 2006 | Five Star BankNEW NAME | $10.9M | +1% |
| Jun 30 2005 | Wyoming County Bank | $10.9M |
Nearest other open offices in Erie County
- 0.3 miCitizens Bank, National Association · 5225 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville
- 0.4 miTompkins Community Bank · 1 Hopkins Rd, Buffalo
- 0.5 miManufacturers and Traders Trust Company · 428 Evans St, Williamsville
- 0.5 miCNB Bank · 5190 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville
- 0.5 miKeyBank National Association · 5173 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville
- 1.0 miNEXTIER BANK, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION · 5877 Main St, Williamsville
- 1.3 miNBT Bank, National Association · 6460 Main St, Williamsville
- 1.4 miChemung Canal Trust Company · 5529 Main St, Buffalo
All banks in Erie County →
Every Five Star Bank office →
Earlier names and banks folded into Five Star Bank →
Names on the sign
2005–2005Wyoming County Bank2006–nowFive Star Bank
The FDIC office number stays with the building when banks merge or rename, so the same office appears under each owner. Follow an earlier name to see what became of that bank.
Deposits are the balances the bank assigned to this office on June 30 of each year, in nominal dollars. Source: FDIC Summary of Deposits, office (UNINUMBR) 439650.